Evidence first

We check photos, hallmarks, serials, maker marks, documents, accessories and condition. For mixed collections, we separate items that need different treatment rather than averaging everything into one vague number.

Market reality

Direct offers are based on what Fair Vintage can responsibly buy, process and resell. Auction estimates, retail replacement values and online asking prices can all differ from a real cash offer.

Seller choice

After the offer, the seller can accept, decline, or ask questions. We do not ask sellers to accept before they see the written offer.